Mealime recipe · lives on in MealPot
Mushroom Sandwich with Avocado-Mayo Spread, Arugula, Tomato & Carrot
- 30 min
- 2–6 servings
- 641 kcal / serving
A mushroom sandwich with a creamy avocado-mayo spread, fresh arugula, tomato, and carrot comes together in about half an hour for a straightforward weeknight lunch. The roasted mushrooms contrast with the smooth, tangy filling for a satisfying bite.
Free on iPhone · servings scaled, grocery list written for you.
Ingredients
- ½avocado
- ½ (5 oz) pkgbaby arugula
- 1 mediumcarrot
- ¼ cupnutritional yeast flakes
- 2 capsportobello mushrooms
- 1tomato
- 4 sliceswhole grain bread
- carrots
- tomatoes
- avocados
From the pantry: balsamic vinegar, black pepper, extra virgin olive oil, garlic powder, mayonnaise, paprika, pure maple syrup, salt, soy sauce
Cookware
baking sheet pan · chef's knife · colander · cutting board · grater · measuring cups · measuring spoons · mixing bowls · oven mitts · potato masher · toaster (optional) · tongs · whisk or fork
Directions
- Preheat the oven to 425°F.
- Wash and dry the produce as you prepare.
- Make a simple marinade by whisking oil, soy sauce, vinegar, maple syrup, paprika, and pepper in a small bowl.
- Trim the mushroom stems and scrape out the gills; place the caps on a baking sheet and coat them with the marinade, turning to cover evenly.
- Roast the mushrooms in the oven until tender, about 10–12 minutes; remove and set aside.
- Halve and pit the avocado, then scoop the flesh into the reserved bowl with the marinade.
- Add nutritional yeast, mayo, and spices to the avocado; mash until smooth to form the spread.
- Slice the tomato and coarsely grate the carrot; set aside with the arugula.
- Slice the mushrooms into strips.
- Toast the bread if desired.
- Spread the avocado mayo on all bread slices; layer with mushrooms, tomato, carrot, and arugula, then cap with the remaining slices.
- Transfer the assembled sandwiches to plates and serve.
Two tips
- Make the avocado-mayo spread in advance and refrigerate for up to a day for quicker assembly.
- If you like extra greens, swap in more arugula or add another tomato slice to the stack.
Nutrition per serving
- Calories
- 641 kcal
- Protein
- 21 g
- Carbs
- 52 g
- Fat
- 42 g
- Fiber
- 14 g
- Sodium
- 389 mg
Estimates from the recipe's published nutrition data; they change with the version you pick above.
More like this
PLAN THE WEEK
One of 1,676 Mealime recipes in MealPot.
Pick five dinners, MealPot writes one grocery list sorted by aisle and scales every recipe to your household.
Ingredient quantities, timing and nutrition are recorded from the original Mealime recipe ↗ (captured 2026-09-12). Photo: MealPot, an AI-rendered illustration of the finished dish. Description and directions written by MealPot.